0

Common Mistakes to Avoid When Converting a Garage to an ADU

By: Alex | Date Posted: July 25, 2025

Converting a garage into an ADU (Accessory Dwelling Unit) is a smart way to add value and flexibility to your property, but skipping the foundational assessment is a hidden mistake that can derail your project from the start. Before dreaming about finishes or fixtures, ask, “Is my garage even suitable for conversion”?

Start by hiring a professional to evaluate the foundation, walls, and roof for structural integrity. Look for signs of moisture, cracks, or pest damage—issues that must be addressed before any construction or insulation begins. Community forums and contractors agree: always check for moisture and foundation problems before installing insulation or moving forward with design plans.

Mistake #1: Navigating the Maze of Permits and Zoning Laws Incorrectly

The most common—and financially devastating—error is skipping or mishandling permits and zoning research. If you don’t secure the right permits, you risk fines, legal headaches, and even being forced to demolish your finished ADU.

Research your city’s ADU regulations, including size, height, setbacks, and parking requirements. Obtain all necessary permits for building, electrical, and plumbing work before commencing. Consulting an architect or surveyor can help you avoid unpleasant surprises down the road.

Mistake #2: The Budget Blowout—Underestimating the Real Costs

Garage-to-ADU conversions typically cost between $80,000 and over $250,000. Many homeowners only budget for construction, overlooking the costs of permits, architectural plans, utility hookups, and high-quality finishes. Include a 15-20% contingency fund for unexpected issues like structural repairs or hidden plumbing problems. Get multiple contractor estimates to avoid hidden expenses and ensure your budget is realistic.

Mistake #3: The Insulation Goldilocks Problem—Too Little is Cold, Too Much is a Mold Factory

Converting a garage requires careful planning—insulation is not just about comfort, it’s about health and long-term durability. While under-insulating leads to cold, drafty spaces and high energy bills, over-insulating an old garage without proper ventilation can trap moisture, leading to mold and poor air quality.

Mistake #4: Flawed Space Planning and Ignoring Livability

A common regret is ending up with a cramped, awkward, or dark ADU. Avoid this by planning for easy movement, smart storage (such as wall-mounted cabinets and multi-functional furniture), and efficient kitchen and bath layouts. Don’t forget natural light—strategically placed windows and skylights can transform a garage from a cave into a welcoming home. For bathrooms, choose an easy-to-install tub insert to maximize space and simplify installation, reducing both labor costs and future maintenance headaches.

Mistake #5: Cutting Corners on Utilities and Safety

Improper electrical or plumbing work is not just inconvenient—it’s dangerous. ADUs often need a dedicated subpanel and upgraded wiring to handle appliances and modern living needs. Plumbing must be properly connected to the main sewer lines, with sufficient water pressure and adequate drainage. Licensed professionals must perform all utility work to meet code and ensure the safety and longevity of your investment.

Mistake #6: Choosing the Wrong Team (Or Thinking DIY is Always Cheaper)

Hiring an inexperienced contractor or attempting complex work yourself is a recipe for disaster. Vet contractors carefully: check licenses, insurance, references, and specific experience with ADUs. DIY can save money on painting or minor finishes, but structural, electrical, and plumbing work should always be left to professionals.

Mistake #7: Forgetting the Future—Resale Value and Flexibility

Losing parking or storage space is a concern, but a well-designed ADU can serve as a rental unit, home office, or in-law suite. A fully permitted, flexible ADU can significantly boost your property value, while an unpermitted or poorly executed one can be a liability.

Frequently Asked Questions About Garage ADU Conversions

What are the main problems with garage conversions?

Skipping permits, underestimating costs, poor insulation/ventilation, bad space planning, and cutting corners on utilities or contractors.

Can you legally turn any garage into an ADU?

Only if your project meets all local zoning and permitting requirements.

Does a garage conversion add more value as a simple living space or as a complete ADU?

A fully functional, independently designed ADU with a kitchen and bath offers the highest ROI.

How much does a garage to ADU conversion cost in 2024/2025?

Expect $80,000–$250,000+, depending on size, finishes, and local labour costs.

Your Blueprint for a Successful Conversion

Avoiding these hidden mistakes is the difference between a dream project and a money pit. Invest in thorough planning, professional consultation, and high-quality solutions, such as the CMI retrofit insulation system, to ensure your ADU remains comfortable, safe, and valuable for years to come. A successful garage-to-ADU conversion is a marathon of careful decisions, not a sprint. Start strong, plan smart, and protect your investment.

Conclusion

Converting a garage into an ADU is more than just a construction project—it’s a strategic investment in your property’s future. Done right, it creates a beautiful, functional space that serves evolving needs, from guest housing to rental income. By planning carefully and avoiding the common pitfalls outlined above, you’ll ensure your project succeeds both practically and financially.

Thank you for reading!